BJ Otten, owner of Colony Builders, leads a full‑service homebuilding team based in Bethel, Maine known for crafting durable, design‑forward custom homes shaped by both his customers and the unique landscape of Western Maine. Colony Builders’ approach centers on clear communication with homeowners and a deep understanding of how space, flow, and craftsmanship come together to enhance everyday living. Drawing on significant residential construction experience, their team builds homes designed to perform through every season—along with a deep-rooted partnership with Hancock Lumber for all their building material needs.
One of Colony Builders most recent projects in Newry, ME—located at the base of Sunday River Ski Resort—demonstrates how deep collaboration and partnership across the homeowner, builder, and supplier makes the vision come to life. Located within The Colony, this 4,030‑square‑foot home is designed to support everyday living while having a luxury feel. BJ and Bridgton Account Manager, Rodney Johnson, worked together to create this beautiful custom home.
Builder: Colony Builders
Type: Residential New Construction
Location: Newry, Maine
Hancock Location: Bridgton
Account Manager: Rodney Johnson
Featured Products:
- Hallmark Alta Vista Cambria Flooring
- Engineered Roof: Coastal Forest Products
- Engineered Wood Package: Anthony Power Products, Nordic I-Joist, and Engineered LVL
- Hancock Pine Clap Boards + 1×10 Pine Shiplap
- Cedar Shakes
- Trex Transcend Decking
- 2-Panel Pine Shaker Interior Doors
- Andersen A series Sliding Doors with 400 Series Andersen Windows
- Smooth Star ThermaTru Exterior Doors
- Certainteed Landmark PRO
Colony Builders is a long‑standing and trusted partner of Hancock Lumber, working closely with Rodney Johnson, Account Manager at Hancock Lumber’s Bridgton lumberyard, for 5+ years.
“I’ve had the pleasure of working with BJ for over five years, and he consistently brings a clear vision and high standards to every project. He’s not only a great person to work with, but also deeply committed to quality and detail—something that’s evident in every home he builds. Over the years, BJ has proven to be a dependable and trusted partner, and that consistency and professionalism are what make our partnership such a strong one.”
–Rodney Johnson, Account Manager, Bridgton
“At Colony Builders, we aren’t just constructing houses—we’re crafting homes with purpose. Every detail, no matter how small, is thoughtfully designed for quality, longevity, and seamless integration into the real lives of our owners. In an industry where shortcuts are too common, we take the opposite approach—planning for comfort, building for durability, and designing for exceptional functionality. The result is homes that aren’t just beautiful, but intentional, livable sanctuaries built to grow with our clients for generations to come.
That commitment is strengthened through trusted partnerships. Rodney Johnson and Hancock Lumber have proven integral to our process of delivering a wholesome, local product with pride, professionalism, and consistency. Our confidence in Rodney as a true extension of our team—mirroring our values of integrity, respect, and follow-through—creates a seamless experience for our staff and our clients. We’re fortunate to work alongside a partner with such strong values.”
— BJ Otten, Owner
If you have a finished project you want featured in our next builder spotlight, please send completed photos and materials list to [email protected]!
